Thelonious Monk’s Harmony, Rhythm, and pianism (Part 3)

Table of Contents
  • Thelonious Monk’s Harmony, Rhythm, and pianism (Part 3)
    • Read Part 1 here and Part 2 here.
  • Rhythm and Pianism
    • Rhythm
    • Pianism
    • Analysis of Two Peers
  • Find and download Thelonious Monk’s sheet music transcriptions in our Library.
  • Thelonious Monk With John Coltrane (1961) (Full Album)

Thelonious Monk’s Harmony, Rhythm, and pianism (Part 3)

Read Part 1 here and Part 2 here.

Rhythm and Pianism


Rhythm

The rhythmic traits for which jazz is known and at which it excels—groove, swing, speed, heat, cool, polyrhythm, conversational interaction among players, dense and irregular improvised motives and phrases, antiphonal call and response, and more—are all but absent in ISC. Most modern jazz group performance emphasizes strict periodicity with terrific forward momentum created by players’ rhythmically propulsive contributions. Formidable mastery, poise, and virtuosity are needed to play.

Tempi are characteristically either fast enough to scare off would-be pretenders, or, just as daringly, cooled off to an unruffled “ballad” speed, and steady in either case. The metric backbone is the succession of harmonies with the beat usually actualized and propelled by the walking quarter notes of the bass and the drums’ “ride” cymbal. Though harmonies change on measure downbeats and sometimes middles, the beats in between—beats and in a four-beat measure—are stressed to create a driving backbeat.

Solo performances and recordings are almost exclusively the provenance of pianists, who could use the left hand to simulate the roles of the rhythm section, with either walking bass lines or the evocation of earlier styles such as stride or boogie-woogie. Monk himself made extensive use of these latter techniques on his own solo records, as well as on the unaccompanied numbers that were generally included in his live sets. Solo performers such as Art Tatum would also “extemporize,” straying from steady time in introductions, quasi-cadenzas, and so on. For Monk, though, a solo ballad like ISC was an opportunity to stretch time in a far more radical manner, eschewing steady time almost completely.

Swing, an idiomatic variation of the timing of the subdivided beat, depends on underlying regularity. It involves a dynamic relationship between measured periodicity and the realm of unmeasured music, rhythmic freedom that can be implied through soloists’ styles. This dynamism in turn references a melodic vernacular—the sense that a soloist is “speaking through their horn.” Some would argue that this has to do with the lyricism of the human voice, others that it represents some kind of middle ground between a discursive, rhetorical European way of making music and a more interactive, poly-rhythmic African approach. Others might say that both are true or that it simply feels good, and that, having been discovered and developed at the turn of the twentieth century, it proved irresistible.

Monk’s ISC can be said to swing only in the colloquial sense of being compellingly musical, that is, simply because he is saying something in a distinctive way. But strictly understood, swing can exist only against a conception of steady time, and in this recording nothing keeps time.

Except fleetingly in a few spots, it is impossible to move the body in any regular pulsation to Monk’s playing. He is clearly not keeping steady time internally—or else he has a very different clock. If we listen intently for the regularity most bodies crave—and which we expect from familiarity with more standard versions of the song—we must jolt in and out of time with him. The slow regular beat of the tune’s harmonic progression remains impassively present, a law both obeyed and mocked. Monk often played solo ballads in this manner, a meditation with outbursts, with an affect both reverent and ironic. In live performance with a group, this number would be surrounded by tunes that swung hard. In other words ISC’s rubato is heard—and is meant to be heard—in terms of the absence of jazz’s most authentic rhythmic traits, and of Monk’s abandonment of them in the service of other qualities.

Pianism

One of the most ergonomic inventions in human history, the piano and its eighty-eight-key action are among jazz’s essential European legacies. Its technology has empowered musical cultures as distant as Burmese and African American to adapt it to their own idioms, extending out from the panoply of European approaches to the instrument on completely unforeseen trajectories. Jazz piano’s trajectories crisscross and meld into a great tradition of their own.

No one gains entrance into the pantheon of jazz pianism without a strongly identifiable voice on the instrument. The differences among pianists are bread and butter to jazz lovers, from earlier era virtuosi like Jelly Roll Morton, James P. Johnson, Fats Waller, Earl Hines, and Art Tatum through beboppers like Bud Powell and Mary Lou Williams and on to a diversity of post-bop players far too numerous to cite or describe. But, as we have said, even among these names Monk comes in at a different angle due to a tightly bound combination of pianistic idiosyncrasies, harmony, and rhythm.

Yet we cannot properly appreciate these elements outside the context of what his peers developed for the instrument.
Keyboard concept, technique, and historical currents conspire to shape pianists’ approaches. All pianists have to consider multiple aesthetic issues determining what kinds of textures to favor in developing a style.

Individual tunes suggest their own approaches, but players develop idioms that carry over from tune to tune. Voicings can be played with from one to ten fingers—or sometimes, in Monk’s case, with flattened palms. Overall motion can be dense or sparse. The hands can be independent or interdependent. One can move freely around the entire keyboard or stay closer to its more conventional, “vocal” center. Nuances of touch, phrasing, and dynamic are essential.

Piano styles also group historically. The “orchestral” ways of playing that developed in jazz’s first few decades were strongly influenced by brass band marches and ragtime, and by the fact that before World War II jazz was primarily dance music. Pianists of those years tended to provide a clear beat and full harmonic support. Some, like bandleader Count Basie, favored economy of notes and texture. In contrast, there was nothing in piano technique or harmony that Art Tatum could not execute astonishingly, nor did he hesitate to infuse most everything he played with the encyclopedia of approaches at his disposal, in all kinds of combinations and throughout the entire range of the keyboard.

Bebop was for listening, not dancing, and its speed an excuse for cutting—that is, outplaying and stumping cohorts. The competition nudged piano technique to become lighter, fleeter, and sparser. The walking bass and drums safeguarded the time so pianists needed to do less in that regard, and the bass register was to some degree forsaken. Bud Powell’s style often rested on a chassis of insistent, rhythmically irregular, somewhat grating left-hand “shells” (the root of the chord played in the bass register, plus the seventh directly above it). Jutting from below, they cut in under single-line right-hand melodies that looped around the upper two-thirds of the keyboard, equaling Charlie Parker’s saxophone lines in their density and irregular phrasing.

In the 50s, jazz cooled off, tributaries of eclectic styles blossomed, and it became necessary to know how to play in many ways. Red Garland could imitate the fast-moving close harmonies of big band saxophone sections in passages featuring thick, parallel, two-handed chords moving with melodic gestures. Wynton Kelly emphasized idiomatic blues riffs. Influences of Cuban and Brazilian styles, and of modern European composition, gradually took root. But in the main, Powell’s saxophone-like approach to the right hand prevailed, while in the left hand many developed harmonically richer voicings, deployed somewhat like Powell’s shells.


Analysis of Two Peers

Compare figure 4.4’s transcriptions of the opening of I Should Care as played by Oscar Peterson and Bill Evans, two strikingly different but equally iconic pianists of the time. Peterson, stylistic and technical heir to Tatum, plays solo here with mid-range voicings of up to eight notes, some with left-hand shells, most containing all triad tones and the seventh. As mentioned earlier, he doubles the harmonic rhythm to quarter-note speed, which allows interpolation of tritone substitution dominants preparing the V and the I chords of mm. 1-2. The Eb7 at m. 1, beat 4 is voiced with a pungent #9 in addition to the seventh chord itself. Peterson exploits the hidden presence of an F# major triad within this sonority, playing it with the right hand to separate it from the Eb major triad

Figure 4.4a. Opening measures of Oscar Peterson’s version of I Should Care (transposed to D from the original key of Bb). From Soul-O!; Oscar Peterson, solo piano.
Figure 4.4b. Opening measures of Bill Evans’s version of I Should Care (transposed to D from the original key of C). From How My Heart Sings!; Bill Evans, piano, Chuck Israels, bass, and Paul Motian, drums.

Figure 4.4a and 4.4b

thelonious monk sheet music

he places in the left. The left-hand triad then slides down in parallel motion to the downbeat of m. 2, but in the right the A# moves to A while the other tones remain in place. This reveals an F# minor triad comprising the third, fifth, and seventh of the DM7. The superpositions of triads and impeccable voice leading of this chord change are of a special richness in this region of the keyboard.

Shooting up in register, the F#7 chord on the second triplet eighth of m. 2, beat V is V of the B7 chord on beat 3, itself an applied V to the Em7 of m. 3. The F#7 is notable for its #9 (A) and the #5 (D), which is perhaps there only because Peterson has omitted the fifth of the chord (C# ; see also figure 4.3, middle column and second row under “Chromatic Tones”). On the next beat, where he brings the melody to a local peak, the fifth (F#) is again omitted, but both thirteenth (G#) and b thirteenth (G) are included. This B7, voiced with the root as an afterbeat, contains additional extension tones C and F that, combined with the others, conceal G# major, F major, C minor, and A diminished triads all at once. This sequence of lavish chords, texturally full and smooth, steady and propelled in rhythm and with a legato touch, give ISC sumptuous treatment.

Evans’s bass player Chuck Israels provides all the chord roots in metrically secure positions, so rather than double them or their rhythm, the pianist parries them with the left hand, playing deft offbeat rhythmic punches that converse polyrhythmically with the right hand’s intricate embellishment of the melody. Beyond this, however, Evan’s chord structures are similar to, albeit thinner than, Peterson’s. He remains in the piano’s central register, and he is equally fastidious about voice leading: the majority of the chord-to-chord connections proceed by step.

The elegantly contoured right-hand line begins by hugging the original tune, but transforms it completely after m. 4 (while still brushing the original C, B, and A in mm. 5-7). Evans sometimes uses melody to enrich the voicings, as when A–F# –D (thirteenth, #eleventh, ninth) is heard over the C7 chord in m. 8. He also gingerly clashes with them by using avoid tones, as with the F (#7) over the F#7b5 in m. 4, or the Eb similarly related to its Em7 harmony two measures later (see figure 4.3, left column and top row under “Chromatic Tones”). In both cases, though, Evans is careful to promptly lead by step to a more consonant resolution: the former moves up to F# at the end of the measure, while the latter goes directly down to D.

As we take up analysis of Monk’s ISC, we will find that features creating continuity in these two short excerpts—stepwise motion, propulsive rhythm, mid-range voicing, and a consistent level of density and dissonance—are missing. Monk did not by any means invent the notion of favoring discontinuities in these parameters. He did not come from nowhere, and it is well established that his style is part of a lineage extending from before Duke Ellington, through Monk, and on to later figures like avantgardist Cecil Taylor, not to mention the many who deliberately emulated Monk in recent decades. To hear those connections is a project for another time that would enable a crucial historical and stylistic narrative. But to frame Monk against the prevailing, more conventionally tasteful modern jazz aesthetics illustrated by figure 4.4 is to hear him at his most inimitable and strange.

thelonious monk sheet music

Find and download Thelonious Monk’s sheet music transcriptions in our Library.

Thelonious Monk With John Coltrane (1961) (Full Album)

Browse in the Library:

Total Records Found in the Library: 12472, showing 120 per page
Artist or Composer / Score nameCoverList of Contents
The Phantom of the Opera – Andrew Lloyd Webber (Piano, Vocal, Guitar) sheet music sheet music pdf
The Physical Basis Of Piano Touch And Tone (By Ortmann Otto) (1925) sheet music score download partitura partition spartiti
The pianist Anthology (28 favorite pieces collection) (1920) free sheet music & scores pdf
The Piano A History In 100 Pieces by Susan Tomes (Book) free sheet music partitura partition noten
The Piano Guys sheet music The Piano Guys
The Piano Guys – O Come O Come Emmanuel free sheet music pdf
The Piano Guys Christmas Together Piano Solo With Optional Cello sheet music partitura partition noten spartiti The Piano Guys Christmas Together Piano Solo With Optional Cello Contents
The Piano Guys Jon Schmidt I Do free sheet music pdf
The Piano Guys Jon Schmidt Piano Solos I The Piano Guys Jon Schmidt Piano Solos I free sheet music & scores pdf download
The Piano Guys Jon Schmidt Piano Solos II The Piano Guys Jon Schmidt Piano Solos II
The Piano Guys Jon Schmidt Piano Solos III The Piano Guys Jon Schmidt Piano Solos III free sheet music & scores pdf download
The Piano Guys Let It Go Disneys Frozen Vivaldis Winter The Piano Guys Let It Go Disneys Frozen Vivaldis Winter
The Piano Guys Michael Meets Mozart The Piano Guys Michael Meets Mozart
The Piano Guys Perfect (piano solo) sheet music pdf
The Piano Odyssey Etudes 1 Celebration Series RCM free scores
The Piano Odyssey Etudes 2 (Celebration Series RCM) free sheet music & scores pdf
The Piano Odyssey Etudes 3 Celebration Series RCM free scores
The Piano Odyssey Etudes 4 (Celebration Series) RCM free sheet music & scores pdf
The Piano Odyssey Repertoire 1 (Celebration Series) RCM free sheet music & scores pdf
The Piano Odyssey Repertoire 10 (Celebration Series) RCM free sheet music & scores pdf
The Piano Odyssey Repertoire 2 (Celebration Series) RCM free sheet music & scores pdf
The Piano Odyssey Repertoire 3 (Celebration Series) RCM free sheet music & scores pdf
The Piano Odyssey Repertoire 4 (Celebration Series) RCM free sheet music & scores pdf
The Piano Odyssey Repertoire 6 (Celebration Series) RCM free sheet music downloadpartitions gratuites Noten spartiti The Piano Odyssey Repertoire 6
The Piano Odyssey Repertoire 7 (Celebration Series) RCM free sheet music & scores pdf
The Piano Odyssey Repertoire 8 (Celebration Series) RCM free sheet music & scores pdf
The Pianoforte And Its Music (By Henry Edward Krehbiel) (1911) sheet music score download partitura partition spartiti
The Pink Floyd Song Book (Guitar) sheet music pdf The Pink Floyd Song Book (Guitar)_compressed
The Pink Panther Full Theme (Musescore File).mscz
The Place I’ll Return To Someday – Final Fantasy Ix (Musescore File).mscz
The Platters – The Great Pretender free sheet music pdf
The Platters Anthology free sheet music & scores pdf download The Platters Anthology
The Polar Express – Believe – Glen Ballard The Polar Express – Believe sheet music
The Polar Express – Selections from free sheet music pdf The Polar Express – Selections from
The Polar Express – When Christmas Comes to Town – Glen Ballard
The Police – Every Breath You Take – Arr. For Guitar (Musescore File).mscz
The Police – Guitar Signature Licks with audio MP3 with TABs sheet music pdf The Police – Guitar Signature Licks
The Police – Play Guitar With The Police (Book + audio MP3) with Tablature free sheet music & pdf scores download Play Guitar With – The Police
The Police – The Best (songbook) Guitar with TABs sheet music The Police – The Best (songbook)
The Police – The Great Songs of The Police Police – The Great Songs of The Police
The Police – Walking on the Moon The Untold Story by Chris Campion (Book) free scores download
The Practical Jazz Guitarist – by Mark White (Berklee Press) free sheet music & scores pdf The Practical Jazz Guitarist – by Mark White
The Pretenders – I’ll Stand By You (Piano, vocal, guitar) free sheet music & pdf scores download
The Princess And The Frog – Randy Newman Easy Piano arr. free sheet music & scores pdf download The Princess And The Frog – Newman R. Easy Piano
The Principles Of Expression In Pianoforte Playing (By Adolph Friedrich Christiani) (1885) sheet music score download partitura partition spartiti
The Producers – Betrayed!, From the Musical by Mel Brooks sheet music download
partitions gratuites Noten spartiti partituras
The Producers Music Theory Handbook May 2023 sheet music download
partitions gratuites Noten spartiti partituras
The Punisher – Money For Everyone – Carlo Siliotto
The Queen – Alexandre Desplat free sheet music pdf
The Quotable Musician From Bach To Tupac (eBook) free sheet music & scores pdf download
The Ragtime songbook songs of – Charters, Ann, ed. 1965 free sheet music & pdf scores download The Ragtime songbook songs of – Charters, Ann, ed (1965)
The Readers Digest Childrens Songbook free sheet music pdf The Readers Digest Childrens Songbook
The Real Boogie Woogie Memphis Slim Piano Solos (1959) Book sheet music pdf
The Real Book 6th Ed sheet music score download partitura partition spartiti noten  The Real Book 6th Ed
The Real Book Jazz Standards In C Version – A Collection of some of the greatest songs of the 20th Century free sheet music pdf The Real Book Jazz Standards In C Version
The Real Book of Blues – 225 great blues Melody Line, chords, lyrics sheet music The Real Book of Blues
The Real Book Of Funk Jazz sheet music score download partitura partition spartiti real book of funk
The Real Book Of Jazz Volume I 5th Edition sheet music pdf sheet music score download partitura partition spartiti real book of jazz
The Real Book of Jazz Volume II (All new) sheet music The Real Book of Jazz Volume II
The Real Book of Jazz Volume III (all new) sheet music The Real Book of Jazz Volume III
The Real Book of Jazz Volume IV for C Instruments free sheet music download
partitions gratuites Noten spartiti partituras The Real Book of Jazz Volume IV for C Instruments
The Real Book of Jazz Volume V The Real Book of Jazz Volume V
The Real Christmas Book Fake free sheet music & scores pdf download The Real Christmas Book Fake
The Real JAZZ Vol. 5 free scores download
The Real Little Classical Fake Book (over 600 Classical Themes and Melodies sheet music score download partitura partition spartiti Real classical fake book sheet music
The Real Rock Book 2 sheet music pdf Real Rock Guitar by Kenn ChipkinThe Real Rock Book 2
The Real Songbook – Bossa Nova 1 Brazilian Jazz Real Book (Sheet Music) The Real Songbook – Bossa Nova 1 Brazilian Jazz Real Book
The Red Book Great Piano Solos free sheet music & scores pdf The Red Book Great Piano Solos
The Reggae Songbook – Music Sales Corporation free sheet music & pdf scores download The Reggae Songbook – Music Sales Corporation
The Ring – End Credits Hans Zimmer sheet music pdf
The Rock Story Edited By Theo Cateforis (Book) free score download
The Rocky Horror Picture Show Science Fiction Double The Rocky Horror Picture Show – Science Fiction Double
The Rolling Stones Let It Bleed Authentic Guitar TABs free noten The Rolling Stones Let It Bleed Authentic Guitar TABs
The Rolling Stones – Best Of (Guitar Bass Drums Songbook) sheet music pdf The Rolling Stones – Best Of (Guitar Bass Drums Songbook)
The Rolling Stones – Get Off Of My Cloud
The Rolling Stones Classics – Volume One – Off The Record (Guitar Bass Drum Songbook) sheet music pdf The Rolling Stones Classics – Volume One- Off The Record (Guitar Bass Drum Songbook)
The Rolling Stones Guitar Play-Along Volume 66 – with audio MP3 embedded with TAB free sheet music & pdf scores download The Rolling Stones Guitar Play
The Rolling Stones Rock Score free sheet music & pdf scores download
The Rolling Stones Songbook (Sheet Music Guitar Tab)
The Russian School of Piano playing 1 free sheet music & scores pdf
The Russian School Of Piano Playing 2 free sheet music & scores pdf
The Sapin (Musescore File).mscz
The School Of Velocity Op 299 No. 1 (Musescore File).mscz
The Scientist – Coldplay Piano Arrangement(1) (Musescore File).mscz
The Secret History of Rock. The Most Influential Bands You’ve Never Heard free score download
The secret Life of Glenn Gould, A Genius in Love, by Michael Clarkson (2010) Biography sheet music pdf ebook
The Shadow Of Your Smile (Musescore File).mscz
The Shadow of your Smile Johnny Mandel Francis Webster Jazz Standard arr. Carsten Gerlitz free sheet music partitura partition noten
The Shadow of your Smile(lead sheet) Mandel & Webster sheet music
The Shadows – 20 Big Hits – Songbook sheet music pdf The Shadows songbook
The Shadows Easy Guitar Hits free download sheet music & scores pdf The Shadows Easy Guitar Hits
The Shape of Water (Alexandre Desplat)
The Shawshank Redemption – Stoic Theme – Thomas Newman
The Simpson’s Theme (Piano) Sheet Music
The Simpsons – Main Title
The Simpsons Baby On Board The-Simpsons-Baby-On-Board
The Simpsons Minimum Wage Nanny The Simpsons Minimum Wage Nanny
The Simpsons Songbook – Danny Elfman The Simpsons songbook
The Simpsons Theme (Musescore File).mscz
The Simpsons Theme by Danny Elfman <img src="https://sheetmusiclibrary.website/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/What-a-wonderful-world-212x300.jpg" alt="sheet music download partitura partition spartiti" width="212" height="300" class="alignnone size-medium wp-image-17629" />
The Sims Build Theme No. 1 sheet music pdf
The Slick Book free sheet music pdf
The Smiths – Anthology free sheet music & scores pdf download The Smiths – Anthology
The Smiths Best Of free sheet music & scores pdf The Smiths Best Of
The Song Is You – Jazz Standard The Song Is You – Jazz Standard
The Song Of Purple Summer (Musescore File).mscz
The Song Of Purple Summer Dunkan Sheik And Steven Sater (Musicals) sheet music score download partitura partition spartiti noten
The Song Writing Genius Within You by Geoffrey Williams (Book)2008 free sheet music & scores pdf
The Sound Of Music – Climb Every Mountain – Julie Andrews
The Sound Of Music – Rodgers & Hammerstein (Sheet Music Book) Vocal selections sheet music pdf The Sound of Music
The Sound Of Silence – Simon & Garfunkel (Musescore File).mscz
The Spirit Of God Like a Fire is Burning Mixed Chrus and Organ or Pino by Mark Wilberg Ssaattbb sheet music download
partitions gratuites Noten spartiti partituras
The Story Of Music From Babylon To The Beatles How Music Has Shaped Civilization (Book) ree sheet music download
partitions gratuites Noten spartiti
The Streets Of Laredo – American Cowboy Song Johnny Cash (Musescore File).mscz
The Strokes – Is This It (guitar with TABs) sheet music score download partitura partition spartiti The Strokes
The Third Man Theme By Anton Karas Guitar TABs sheet music download
partitions gratuites Noten spartiti partituras
The Three Tenors Songbook (for high voice and piano) free sheet music pdf The Three Tenors Songbook
The Time Machine – The Eloi – Klaus Badelt The Time Machine The Eloi Klaus Badelt 1st page
The Tokens – The Lion Sleeps Tonight (Piano Solo arr. sheet music, Noten, partitura, partition) sheet music download
partitions gratuites Noten spartiti partituras
The Tokens – The_Lion_Sleeps_Tonight Piano Solo arr.mscz

Alto Saxophone – Gigi Gryce (# A3, B2)…. Bass – Wilbur Ware (# A1 to B2)…. Drums – Art Blakey (#A3, B2), “Shadow” Wilson (#A1, A2, B1)…. Piano – Thelonious Monk…. Tenor Saxophone – Coleman Hawkins (# A3, B2), John Coltrane…. Trumpet – Ray Copeland (# A3, B2)…. ……………………………………………… A1 Ruby, My Dear 0:00 A2 Trinkle, Tinkle 6:22 A3 Off Minor 13:03 B1 Nutty 18:19 B2 Epistrophy 24:58 B3 Functional 28:09 ……………………………………………… Recorded – New York; 1957-58.

sheet music library

It’s nice to meet you.

Sign up to receive our new posts in your inbox.

This field is required.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.