Remembering John Dowland (1563-1626)

Remembering John Dowland (1563-1626)

Best Sheet Music download from our Library.

Please, subscribe to our Library.

If you are already a subscriber, please, check our NEW SCORES’ page every month for new sheet music. THANK YOU!

---

The Sorrowful Joy: An Exhaustive Portrait of John Dowland, The Renaissance Melancholist

In the pantheon of English music, few figures cast a shadow as long, poignant, and beautifully somber as John Dowland. A composer of unparalleled grace and technical mastery, he transformed personal sorrow into a universal language, giving voice to the Elizabethan and Jacobean era’s fascination with melancholy. More than just a lute virtuoso or a songwriter, Dowland was a cultural phenomenon—an international star whose music traversed courts and continents, captivating audiences with its intricate beauty and profound emotional depth. This article provides an exhaustive exploration of his life, his music, his legacy, and the enduring power of his art.

I. The Man of Sorrows: A Biographical Sketch

The details of Dowland’s early life are shrouded in the typical obscurity of the 16th century, but the fragments paint a picture of a gifted and ambitious man.

Early Life and Conversion (1563-1585)
John Dowland was born in 1563, possibly in London or Westminster. Little is known of his family, but by 1580, he was in service to Sir Henry Cobham, the English Ambassador to the French court. This Parisian sojourn was formative, exposing the young musician to the sophisticated lute culture of the Continent. Crucially, it was during this time that he converted to Roman Catholicism—a decision that would haunt his career in Protestant England. He returned to England in 1584 and earned a Bachelor of Music degree from Christ Church, Oxford, in 1588.

The Elusive English Post and European Wanderings (1588-1598)
Despite his growing reputation as a lutenist, Dowland failed to secure a position in the court of Queen Elizabeth I. The reasons are not entirely clear, but his Catholic faith is widely believed to have been a significant obstacle. Frustrated, he embarked on a period of travel that established his international fame.

His journey took him to the epicenters of European music:

• Germany: He visited the court of the Duke of Brunswick-Wolfenbüttel and the Landgrave of Hesse.
• Italy: He went to Venice and Florence, where he encountered the revolutionary Florentine Camerata, who were developing the first operas. In his own writings, Dowland later claimed he was invited to join a group of English Catholic plotters in Florence, a claim that may have been an attempt to prove his Protestant loyalty or simply an embellishment.
• Denmark: His most significant appointment came in 1598 when he became lutenist to King Christian IV of Denmark, one of Europe’s most generous musical patrons. His salary was immense, reflecting his superstar status.

This period was his most prolific. In 1597, he published his groundbreaking first book of Songes or Ayres, which brought him immense fame and wealth.

Return to England and Late Recognition (1606-1626)
Dowland’s extravagant spending led to his dismissal from the Danish court in 1606. He returned to England, still without a court position. He worked as a highly sought-after teacher and composer for the aristocracy. Finally, in 1612, with the reign of the more religiously tolerant James I, Dowland achieved his lifelong goal: he was appointed one of the “King’s Musicians for the Lutes” at the English court. He held this position until his death in London, likely in early 1626. His final years saw the publication of his last great work, A Pilgrimes Solace (1612), and his monumental collection of instrumental music, Lachrimae (1604).

II. The Musical Output: A Legacy in Print and Manuscript

Dowland was one of the first composers to successfully leverage the new technology of music printing, ensuring the survival and widespread dissemination of his work. His output can be divided into three main categories.

1. The Ayres (Solo Songs with Lute Accompaniment)
This is the core of Dowland’s fame. Published in four influential books (1597, 1600, 1603, and the late A Pilgrimes Solace in 1612), these “ayres” represent the pinnacle of the English lute-song tradition.

• Form: Typically written for a solo voice (often a high tenor) accompanied by a lute. They were ingeniously printed in a “table-book” format, allowing performers to sit around a table and read from the same sheet—the singer seeing the vocal part one way up, the lutenist the tablature another.
• Style: Dowland’s genius lay in the perfect marriage of text and music. The lute accompaniment is not merely harmonic support; it is a contrapuntal partner to the voice, weaving intricate lines that illustrate and amplify the meaning of the poetry. The melodies are often deceptively simple, graceful, and instantly memorable.
• Themes: The texts, many of which Dowland may have written himself, are dominated by themes of melancholy, unrequited love, fortune’s fickleness, death, and solitude. This was not merely self-pity; it was a fashionable and philosophical stance, deeply connected to the Renaissance concept of the melancholic genius.

2. Lute Solos
As the foremost lute virtuoso of his age, Dowland composed a vast body of work for solo lute. These pieces demonstrate his breathtaking technical command and profound musical imagination.

• Forms: He worked in the standard dance forms of the day: the stately Pavan, the lively Galliard, the energetic Almain, and the virtuosic Fantasia.
• Masterpieces: Many of his lute solos are among the most famous instrumental works of the era. Pieces like Lachrimae Pavan (which became a European hit), My Lord Willoughby’s Welcome Home, The Frog Galliard, and Sir John Smith his Almain showcase a perfect blend of lyrical invention, complex counterpoint, and rhythmic vitality.

3. Consort Music
Dowland also composed for instrumental ensembles. His most famous work in this genre is the 1604 collection Lachrimae, or Seaven Teares Figured in Seaven Passionate Pavans.

• Lachrimae: This is a cycle of seven pavans for a consort of viols and lute. Each pavan is a variation on the descending four-note motif from his famous Lachrimae lute pavan. It is a deeply intellectual and emotional work, one of the first of its kind in English music, exploring the theme of tears through a series of profound and intricate musical meditations.
• Other Works: He also composed other works for viol consort and adapted his ayres for this medium.

III. The Anatomy of Melancholy: Signature Works and Musical Style

To understand Dowland is to understand his musical portrayal of sorrow.

Signature Works:

• “Flow, my tears” (from Second Booke of Songes or Ayres, 1600): This is the quintessential Dowland song. Its text is a perfect expression of self-exiled melancholy, and its falling, sighing melody is unforgettable. The song became so popular that it spawned an entire instrumental genre, the “lachrimae” (tears) pavan.
• “In darkness let me dwell”: Perhaps his most radical and intense song. From A Pilgrimes Solace, its dissonant harmonies, dark texture, and bleak text push the boundaries of Renaissance tonality to express a state of near-total despair.
• “Come, heavy sleep” & “Come again, sweet love doth now invite”: These songs showcase his range—the first a somber invocation of sleep as the image of death, the second a more optimistic, graceful, and dance-like love song.
• Lachrimae Antiquae: The original lute pavan that started the “tears” phenomenon. Its haunting, stepwise descending opening motif became one of the most recognizable musical themes of the era.

Musical Style and Techniques:

• Text Painting: Dowland was a master of musica reservata, the technique of using music to literally “paint” the meaning of the words. A word like “sigh” would be set to a descending interval; “fall” would see the melody drop; “darkness” would be accompanied by a low, somber harmony.
• Dissonance and Chromaticism: He used controlled dissonance and unexpected chromatic shifts to create a sense of tension, pain, and emotional complexity, far beyond many of his contemporaries.
• Complex Lute Writing: His lute parts are polyphonic marvels, independent yet perfectly supportive. They require a high level of technical skill to execute their intricate inner voices and rhythmic subtleties.
• The “Dowland Rhythm”: A specific, syncopated rhythmic figure (a long note followed by two short ones) appears frequently in his galliards and other works, becoming a signature of his style.

IV. The Dowland Persona: Melancholy as a Brand

Dowland actively cultivated his image as “Semper Dowland, semper dolens” (Always Dowland, always doleful), a motto he used in his 1612 publication. This was not merely a personal affectation; it was a savvy artistic brand. In Renaissance England, melancholy was associated with intellectual depth, sensitivity, and genius (as later detailed in Robert Burton’s The Anatomy of Melancholy). By embodying this figure, Dowland positioned himself not as a mere entertainer, but as a profound artist plumbing the depths of the human condition.

V. Legacy and Rediscovery

After his death, Dowland’s music fell into obscurity, as the Baroque era’s new styles supplanted the Renaissance polyphonic ideal. He was remembered only as a name in historical records for nearly 300 years.

His rediscovery began in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, fueled by the Early Music Revival. Scholars like Edmund Fellowes began transcribing and publishing his work. However, it was the mid-20th century that saw a true Dowland renaissance, led by two figures:

1. Alfred Deller: The legendary countertenor, with lutenist Desmond Dupré, made groundbreaking recordings that revealed the sublime beauty and emotional power of the ayres to a modern audience.
2. Julian Bream: The classical guitarist and lutenist became a tireless champion of Dowland’s lute music, recording the complete works and demonstrating their technical and artistic brilliance for a new generation.

Today, Dowland’s music is more popular than ever. It is performed by early music specialists, classical singers, rock musicians (like Sting, whose 2006 album Songs from the Labyrinth introduced Dowland to a vast new audience), and folk artists. His work continues to resonate because it speaks a fundamental truth about the human experience: that sorrow, when rendered with such artistry and honesty, can be a source of profound beauty and connection.

John Dowland: The Enduring Tears

John Dowland was a paradox: a technical master who valued emotional expression above all, an international celebrity who felt himself an outsider, and a man who made a career from sorrow yet brought immense joy to his listeners. His music represents the final, flawless flowering of the English Renaissance. In his pavans, galliards, and ayres, we find not the simplistic gloom the word “melancholy” might suggest, but a vast and nuanced emotional landscape—a world of introspective depth, poetic sensitivity, and unparalleled beauty. He remains, as the title of one of his most famous pieces suggests, the timeless “Instructor of Sorrows,” and his music continues to flow, like his eternal tears, touching the hearts of listeners centuries after his silent departure.

---

The influence of John Dowland extends far beyond the realm of early music, casting a long shadow over composers and musicians from the 20th and 21st centuries. The stories of Sting and Benjamin Britten are particularly illuminating, as they represent two vastly different, yet equally profound, engagements with his work.

Benjamin Britten: The Modernist’s Homage

The Story:
Benjamin Britten, one of the most important English composers of the 20th century, had a lifelong fascination with the music of the English Renaissance. For the Aldeburgh Festival in 1960, he was commissioned to write a piece for the countertenor Alfred Deller—the very man who had been central to the Dowland revival. The result was Lachrymae, Reflections on a Song of John Dowland, Op. 48.

The piece is not a simple arrangement but a deep, intellectual, and emotional dialogue with the past. Britten takes Dowland’s most famous emblem, the lute song “Flow, my tears” (the source of the Lachrimae pavan), and deconstructs it.

The Musical Connection:

• Structure: Lachrymae is a set of variations for viola and piano, but it is structured in reverse. It begins in the shadowy, ambiguous sound world of modernism. The listener hears fragments, dissonant echoes, and melancholic sighs drawn from Dowland’s original melody, but they are obscured, as if heard through a glass, darkly.
• The Journey: Throughout the variations, Britten gradually “cleans” the music, stripping away the 20th-century dissonances and complexities. The variations move through different emotional states, each one a “reflection” on the theme of tears.
• The Revelation: The piece culminates in its final moments. After this journey of abstraction, the original Dowland song emerges in its full, pristine, and heartbreakingly simple form, now played by the piano with the viola weaving a descant above it. It is a moment of breathtaking clarity and emotional release, as if the centuries of fog have finally parted to reveal the timeless beauty of the original.

Significance: Britten’s work is a masterpiece of modernism engaging with antiquity. It doesn’t mimic Dowland’s style; it uses a contemporary musical language to meditate on the very essence of Dowland’s melancholy, ultimately affirming its enduring power. It is a composer’s homage, a conversation across 400 years about the universal language of sorrow.

Sting: The Pop Star’s Pilgrimage

The Story:
In 2006, the former frontman of The Police, Sting, released an album titled Songs from the Labyrinth, dedicated entirely to the music of John Dowland. This was not a casual side project. Sting had been an admirer since his teen years, when a teacher played him “Flow, my tears.” He was captivated by the directness of the emotion, comparing it to the blues.

The album was a collaboration with Bosnian lutenist Edin Karamazov. Sting saw in Dowland a kindred spirit: a fellow melancholic, a brilliant technician, and a “rock star” of his day who felt like an outsider. He was particularly drawn to Dowland’s personal story of professional disappointment and his cultivated “doleful” persona.

The Musical Connection:

• Interpretation, Not Replication: Sting did not attempt to sing like a classically trained early music tenor. Instead, he used his distinctive, breathy, rock-inflected baritone. This was a conscious choice to highlight the raw, conversational, and deeply personal quality of the lyrics.
• Emphasis on the Text: By stripping away any pretense of “classical” vocal production, Sting focused intensely on the poetry. He treated the songs as deeply personal monologues, making the themes of isolation, betrayal, and sorrow feel immediate and modern.
• Narrative Framing: The album is interspersed with readings from Dowland’s famously self-pitying and revealing letter to Sir Robert Cecil, painting a vivid portrait of the composer’s frustrations. This contextualized the music within the man’s life story.

Significance: Sting’s project was arguably the most significant act of popularization for Dowland since the early music revival began. It introduced his music to a massive global audience who would likely never have encountered it otherwise. It demonstrated that Dowland’s emotional core—his “sorrowful joy”—was not locked in a museum but was a living, breathing art form that could speak directly to a 21st-century sensibility.

Other Notable Engagements

The fascination with Dowland extends well beyond Britten and Sting. Here are a few other significant stories:

1. Kaikhosru Shapurji Sorabji (1892-1988):
This famously complex and reclusive British composer wrote Pastiche on the “Pavane Lachrymae” of John Dowland in 1927. True to Sorabji’s style, it is a densely textured, virtuosic work for piano that takes Dowland’s simple, elegant pavan and expands it into a massive, ornate, and harmonically labyrinthine structure. It’s a transformation of Renaissance melancholy into a late-Romantic, almost decadent, sound world.

2. Gavin Bryars (b. 1943):
The English minimalist and experimental composer has frequently drawn on early music. His piece In Nomine (After Dowland) uses the iconic In Nomine structure (a popular Renaissance form) as a jumping-off point. More directly, his “The Dowland Project” is an ensemble he formed with singer John Potter (former member of the Hilliard Ensemble). The group improvises around Dowland’s music, exploring the spaces between the notes and treating the skeletal lute songs as a basis for jazz-like improvisation and ambient exploration, asking “what might early seventeenth century improvisation have sounded like?”

3. Peter Maxwell Davies (1934-2016):
Another giant of 20th-century British music, Davies shared Britten’s interest in early forms. His monumental Seven In Nomine (1963-65) uses the In Nomine theme as a basis for modern re-imaginings. While not exclusively about Dowland, the work exists in the same tradition of engaging with Renaissance polyphony through a modernist lens.

4. Judith Weir (b. 1954):
The current Master of the King’s Music has also drawn inspiration from Dowland. Her piece The King’s Singers’ Dowland is an arrangement of several Dowland songs for the famous vocal ensemble, showcasing the intricate part-writing and harmonic richness of the originals in a new, purely vocal format.

A Continuous Thread

The stories of these artists reveal a common thread: they are not merely “covering” Dowland. They are engaging in a dialogue with him.

• Britten conducted a structural and harmonic analysis across time, deconstructing and reconstructing the music to find its core.
• Sting conducted an emotional and biographical exploration, connecting with the man behind the music and presenting his songs as living folk art.
• Sorabji and Bryars represent two poles of re-composition: one through maximalist complexity, the other through minimalist deconstruction and improvisation.

Together, they prove that John Dowland is not a relic but a timeless source of inspiration. His music provides a perfect, crystalline structure—a “labyrinth” of emotion and technique—that subsequent generations of artists feel compelled to enter, each finding their own way through and emerging with a unique testament to his enduring genius.

Search your favorite sheet music in the Sheet Music Catalog

Listen to John Dowland music on Spotify